Asylum Interview in San Diego: What to Expect and How to Prepare

Quick Answer

San Diego's position as the primary port of entry on the U.S.-Mexico border makes it one of the most active asylum processing locations in the country. The USCIS Asylum Office serving San Diego is the San Diego Asylum Office located in San Diego, and asylum cases in removal proceedings are heard at the San Diego Immigration Court. For asylum seekers from Arab countries — including Syria, Iraq, Yemen, Libya, Egypt, and other nations — who have made their way to Southern California, the asylum interview is the most critical moment in their case. A well-prepared interview can mean the difference between protection in the United States and return to persecution. SoCal Immigration Services at (714) 421-8872 represents asylum applicants throughout the San Diego region and across Southern California, with Arabic-speaking attorneys and advocates experienced in asylum cases from the Arab world.

Reviewed for accuracy by

Maria Santos

DOJ Accredited Representative • 15+ years experience

Understanding the Two Types of Asylum Interviews

Before preparing for your asylum interview, you must understand which type of interview you face. The two types operate under different rules, different adjudicators, and different standards. Affirmative asylum applies to individuals who are not in removal proceedings — they proactively file Form I-589 (Application for Asylum and Withholding of Removal) with USCIS, and their interview is conducted by a USCIS Asylum Officer, a trained specialist, in a non-adversarial setting. The interview is not a trial — the officer asks questions to understand and evaluate your claim. Defensive asylum applies to individuals in removal proceedings before an immigration judge — their asylum claim is presented as a defense against removal. The hearing is more formal and adversarial, with a government attorney (ICE attorney) who may cross-examine you. San Diego has both the USCIS Asylum Office for affirmative cases and the San Diego Immigration Court for defensive cases. Your attorney at SoCal Immigration Services will explain which process applies to you.

•Affirmative asylum: Filed with USCIS proactively; interview with Asylum Officer; non-adversarial
•Defensive asylum: Filed in removal proceedings; hearing before immigration judge; adversarial
•Affirmative denial: Case referred to immigration court for defensive hearing — not a final denial
•One-year filing deadline: Must file Form I-589 within one year of arrival (exceptions exist)
•Both types use same Form I-589 and require same core evidence
•San Diego USCIS Asylum Office handles affirmative cases from San Diego County and surrounding areas
•Executive Office for Immigration Review (EOIR) San Diego handles defensive cases

Before the Interview: Essential Preparation Steps

The most important work in an asylum case happens before the interview. Insufficient preparation is the primary reason asylum cases are denied at interview. SoCal Immigration Services begins interview preparation weeks before the scheduled date.

1
Step 1: Complete Form I-589 meticulously — every question must be answered fully and truthfully; inconsistencies between the written application and oral testimony are the most common basis for adverse credibility findings
2
Step 2: Write a detailed personal declaration (signed statement) describing your persecution in chronological order — this supplements Form I-589 and allows you to tell your story with full detail
3
Step 3: Gather country condition evidence — U.S. State Department Country Reports, Human Rights Watch reports, Amnesty International documentation, and news articles establishing the dangerous conditions in your home country
4
Step 4: Collect supporting documents: police reports, medical records showing injuries from persecution, arrest warrants, threatening letters, photographs, news articles about events you witnessed or were part of
5
Step 5: Obtain supporting affidavits from witnesses — family members, neighbors, or community members who witnessed the persecution or can corroborate your account
6
Step 6: Arrange a qualified interpreter if you need one — USCIS provides interpreters but you have the right to bring your own (not a family member or attorney)
7
Step 7: Conduct mock interview sessions with your attorney — practice answering questions about your claim clearly and consistently
8
Step 8: Organize your evidence into a clear, tabbed exhibit binder — officers appreciate organized presentations and it demonstrates the seriousness of your preparation

Common Asylum Interview Questions and How to Answer Them

USCIS Asylum Officers and Immigration Judges follow a structured interview format, though questions vary based on the specific facts of each case. Understanding the types of questions asked allows applicants to prepare thoughtful, consistent answers. The core questions center on establishing the five protected grounds for asylum: race, religion, nationality, political opinion, or membership in a particular social group. For Arab asylum seekers in San Diego, common scenarios involve persecution by governments, sectarian violence, persecution of religious minorities, and threats related to political activism or journalism.

•Identity verification: 'Tell me your full name, date of birth, and where you were born' — answer exactly as listed in your passport and I-589
•Travel history: 'Describe your travel from your home country to the United States' — know every country you transited and dates traveled
•Persecution narrative: 'Why do you fear returning to your country?' — this is the heart of your case; answer clearly and completely
•Specific incidents: 'Tell me exactly what happened on [date]' — describe specific incidents of persecution with dates, locations, and names of perpetrators if known
•Government inability/unwillingness: 'Did you report the persecution to police?' — explain why authorities could not or would not protect you
•Nexus to protected ground: 'Why do you believe you were targeted?' — connect your persecution to race, religion, nationality, political opinion, or social group
•Future fear: 'What do you believe will happen if you return?' — describe the specific harm you fear and why you believe it will occur
•Corroboration: 'Do you have any documents that support what you are telling me?' — present your organized evidence binder

Your Right to an Interpreter and How to Use It Effectively

Arabic-speaking asylum applicants in San Diego have the absolute right to an interpreter throughout the asylum interview process. At the USCIS Asylum Office, USCIS will provide a telephonic or in-person interpreter for your language if you request one in advance on your interview notice response. You also have the right to bring your own interpreter — subject to restrictions (the interpreter cannot be your attorney or a family member). Before bringing a private interpreter, confirm with your attorney that your chosen interpreter is qualified and does not have any conflict of interest. Poor interpretation is a serious concern in asylum cases — a mistranslated word can create apparent inconsistencies that undermine credibility. SoCal Immigration Services recommends reviewing your interpreter's qualifications carefully and conducting at least one practice session with your attorney and the interpreter together before the interview. At any point during the interview, you have the right to stop and request clarification of a question, and the right to request that the interpreter repeat a translation if you believe it was inaccurate.

•Request Arabic interpreter in advance on interview notice response form
•USCIS provides telephonic or in-person interpreters at no cost
•Right to bring your own interpreter (not attorney, not family member)
•Interpreter must be fluent in both Arabic and English — dialectal competency matters
•If Syrian, Iraqi, Egyptian, or Levantine Arabic — confirm interpreter's dialect
•Right to stop and ask for question clarification at any time
•Right to challenge an incorrect translation during the interview
•Poor interpretation creates reversible error — raise concerns immediately, not after the interview

What Asylum Officers and Immigration Judges Look for: Credibility

Credibility is the cornerstone of asylum cases. An Asylum Officer or Immigration Judge grants asylum based on belief that your testimony is truthful and that the facts you describe legally qualify you for protection. Adverse credibility findings — a conclusion that your testimony is not believable — result in denial. The REAL ID Act (2005) established the current credibility standard: officers may consider any inconsistency, inaccuracy, or falsehood, regardless of whether it goes to the heart of the claim. Understanding what undermines credibility helps applicants prepare honest, accurate testimony.

•Consistency: Your testimony must be consistent with your written I-589 and your personal declaration — officers compare these closely
•Specificity: Vague, general answers suggest fabrication — specific details (dates, names, locations, words spoken) demonstrate truthfulness
•Plausibility: Your account must be internally logical and consistent with known country conditions
•Demeanor: Officers observe your affect, hesitations, and emotional responses — these are not determinative but are noted
•Corroboration: Documents supporting your account strengthen credibility — absence of corroboration can be explained but requires justification
•Prior statements: Any prior inconsistent statement (in another proceeding, CBP interview, or other context) will be explored
•Omissions: Significant facts in your testimony not included in your I-589 create adverse credibility issues

Evidence Presentation at the San Diego Asylum Interview

Presenting evidence effectively at the asylum interview is a skill that separates successful cases from denied ones. SoCal Immigration Services prepares complete, organized evidence packages for every San Diego asylum client. The evidence must establish: (1) your identity, (2) that you suffered past persecution or have a well-founded fear of future persecution, (3) that the persecution is on account of a protected ground, and (4) that your government cannot or will not protect you. For Arab asylum seekers, key categories of evidence include official government documents (arrest warrants, military conscription notices), medical records documenting injuries, photographs of injuries or destroyed property, affidavits from witnesses, and country condition documentation from reputable sources.

•Identity documents: Passport, national ID card, birth certificate — all with certified translations
•Persecution evidence: Arrest warrants, threatening letters, police reports, hospital records of injuries
•Photographs: Photos of injuries, destroyed home or property, protest participation, news coverage
•Country condition reports: DOS Country Reports (2025/2026 edition), HRW, Amnesty International, UNHCR
•Witness affidavits: Signed, sworn statements from people who witnessed events or know your situation
•Media documentation: News articles (in Arabic with certified translation) documenting events relevant to your case
•Expert opinion letters: Academic or regional experts on country conditions can strengthen complex cases
•Organize evidence in tabbed binder with index — present to officer at start of interview

Timeline and What Happens After Your San Diego Asylum Interview

Understanding the timeline after your asylum interview reduces anxiety and helps you plan. Affirmative asylum interviews at the San Diego Asylum Office result in a decision communicated to you by mail, typically within 2 to 3 weeks of your interview. However, some cases require additional research, security checks, or supervisor review, extending the timeline to 6 to 12 weeks or longer. If USCIS grants asylum, you receive a Form I-94 endorsement and can apply for a green card after one year. If USCIS denies your affirmative asylum claim, your case is referred to immigration court for a removal hearing — this is NOT a deportation order. You will have another opportunity to present your case before an immigration judge. For defensive asylum cases before the San Diego Immigration Court, the judge issues a decision at or following the merits hearing. An immigration judge's denial can be appealed to the Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA) and potentially to the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals.

•Affirmative interview decision: typically 2-3 weeks (can extend to 6+ weeks for complex cases)
•Defensive hearing: Judge may decide same day or within weeks after hearing
•Asylum grant: Receive I-94 with 'refugee' status; apply for green card after 1 year (Form I-485)
•Affirmative denial: Case referred to immigration court — not a final denial
•Defensive denial: Can appeal to Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA) within 30 days
•BIA denial: Can petition Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals (for San Diego cases)
•Work authorization: File Form I-765 (EAD) 150 days after filing I-589 if no interview yet
•Withholding of removal and CAT protection: Alternative forms of relief if asylum is denied

Contact SoCal Immigration Services for San Diego Asylum Representation

The asylum interview is not a process to navigate alone. Legal representation dramatically increases asylum approval rates — represented asylum applicants are approximately 3 times more likely to be granted asylum than unrepresented applicants, according to TRAC Immigration data. SoCal Immigration Services provides full asylum representation for clients throughout San Diego County and Southern California, including case evaluation, Form I-589 preparation, evidence compilation, personal declaration drafting, mock interview preparation, and courtroom representation. Our Arabic-speaking attorneys understand the political, cultural, and religious contexts of asylum claims from Syria, Iraq, Yemen, Libya, Egypt, Jordan, Lebanon, and all other Arab countries. Call us at (714) 421-8872 to schedule an asylum consultation.

FAQFrequently Asked Questions

Q:How long does an asylum interview at the San Diego USCIS office take?

A: Affirmative asylum interviews at the USCIS Asylum Office typically take 2 to 4 hours, though complex cases can last longer. Defensive merits hearings before an immigration judge can take a full day or multiple days depending on complexity. Plan to arrive early and expect the interview to run its full course.

Q:Can I bring a family member to translate at my asylum interview?

A: No. Family members cannot serve as interpreters at USCIS asylum interviews. Your attorney also cannot serve as your interpreter. You must bring an independent, qualified interpreter or use the interpreter USCIS provides. USCIS provides interpreters at no cost if you request one when you respond to your interview notice.

Q:What happens if I forget a detail during the interview that is in my I-589?

A: Do not guess or fabricate an answer. If you cannot remember a specific detail, say so clearly: 'I cannot recall the exact date, but I know it was in approximately [month/year].' Honest acknowledgment of memory limitations is treated more favorably than inconsistent answers. Your attorney can help you prepare by reviewing your I-589 thoroughly before the interview.

Q:My asylum case involves events in Syria that I cannot document because records were destroyed. Will this hurt my case?

A: Not necessarily. USCIS understands that applicants from conflict zones often cannot obtain documentation. Country condition evidence (DOS reports, HRW, Amnesty International) documenting conditions in Syria can substitute for personal documentation in many cases. Witness affidavits, photographs, and your detailed testimony are also valid evidence. Call SoCal Immigration Services at (714) 421-8872 to discuss your documentation options.

Q:If my affirmative asylum application is denied, is that the end of my case?

A: No. An affirmative asylum denial from USCIS refers your case to immigration court — it is not a final denial or a deportation order. You will have a full hearing before an immigration judge where you can present your case again with an attorney. This is a separate, independent proceeding from the USCIS interview.

Q:I was detained at the San Diego border and am in removal proceedings. Can I still apply for asylum?

A: Yes. Individuals in removal proceedings can apply for asylum as a defense (defensive asylum) before an immigration judge. You file Form I-589 with the immigration court. Being detained does not prevent you from seeking asylum, and you have the right to legal representation, though the government does not provide a free attorney. Call (714) 421-8872 immediately.

Q:How is the one-year filing deadline calculated for asylum applications?

A: The one-year deadline is calculated from your last arrival in the United States. You must file Form I-589 within one year of that date. Exceptions exist for changed circumstances (new conditions in your home country) and extraordinary circumstances (serious illness, legal disability, ineffective assistance of counsel). Missing the deadline without an applicable exception bars you from asylum, though you may still qualify for withholding of removal.

Q:What is the difference between asylum and withholding of removal?

A: Asylum provides the most protection: refugee status, green card eligibility after one year, and the ability to bring family members. Withholding of removal prevents deportation to the country of persecution but does not provide a path to permanent residence and does not allow you to bring family members. Withholding requires a higher legal standard (clear probability of persecution vs. well-founded fear). Convention Against Torture (CAT) protection is a third option for those who face torture.

Disclaimer: This article provides general information about immigration services in San Diego and does not constitute legal advice. SoCal Immigration Services is a document preparation company, not a law firm. For legal advice specific to your situation, please consult with a licensed immigration attorney.

Published: February 18, 2026Last Updated: February 18, 2026

Get Professional Help Today

Our experienced team is ready to assist you with your immigration needs.

Serving San Diego and all of Southern California

Schedule a Consultation (714) 421-8872

asylum•El Cajon